Don’t sweat Thanksgiving menu! It always works.

From Beverly Mills   |  November 23, 2009
In Coffee and Convo, Kitchen Basics
Featured Recipe: Pumpkin, Sweet Potato and Peanut Soup

Pumpkin, Sweet Potato and Peanut Soup

Cooking the Thanksgiving feast tends to stress people out. Not me. It’s a lot of work, but it’s predictable and premeditated. You don’t need to make a bunch of decisions and you don’t have to worry whether your menu is up to snuff. On Thanksgiving, you just cook traditional stuff and everyone overeats then heads for the couch.

On all other days besides Thanksgiving, if your menu is not up to snuff, guests will be passing judgment. Maybe I’m imagining this. Polite guests would never pass judgment. But I have, on occasion, been an impolite guest. I am probably a horrible person. Or just menopausal.

But back to Thanksgiving.

Nobody is a horrible person when Macy’s has been strutting marching bands all day and turkey smells are wafting around. I scour food magazines for weeks beforehand – this is enough to make anyone think their menu will never be up to snuff – and cooking Thanksgiving still doesn’t worry me. I know that deep down, people just want the same old menu.

Sure there are the deal breakers: Stuff the turnkey/don’t stuff it; rice or mashed potatoes; giblets in the gravy vs. smooth, marshmallows on top of the sweet potatoes or not? But these debates are easily mediated. Take a vote beforehand, and if necessary, cook it both ways.

Everybody wins at Thanksgiving. Especially me. I just cook, and smile, and cook, and sip.

I’ve made all of these recipes so many times they’re practically memorized, and they were handed down to me from Ages Past. The real proof? No guest, not ever, not once, has done anything to make me believe they were anything less than perfectly satisfied at the Thanksgiving table. And I would know if they were faking it. But more importantly, on this one day, I simply wouldn’t care.

So now I'm curious: What's the lineup for your Thanksgiving menu this year?

Comments

From Beverly Mills - November 23, 2009

From Blanca, via Facebook: I'm going to try making the soup. But I'm not sure about adding the peanut butter. Can that be skipped? What does it add?

From Beverly Mills - November 23, 2009

Well, it sort of gives the soup a peanut-y underpinning of flavor. A sort of depth, I guess. If you're not a peanut fan, leave it out!

From Kelly @ Love Well - November 23, 2009

I have the same mixed feelings about Thanksgiving. I love looking at new recipes and tinkering with the final line-up. Every once in a while, something new goes in and something old goes out. But for the most part, my menu has stayed the same for a few years now. I posted <a href="http://lovewell.blogspot.com/2008/11/thanksgiving-dinner-2008-final-cut.html">my finalized 2008 Thanksgiving menu</a> on my blog, and this year's won't deviate except for the pies. (I'm sticking with traditional pumpkin this year, adding in a chocolate cream and switching the regular apple for an apple-pear crostada.)

From Beverly Mills - November 23, 2009

My "traditional" pecan pies (Granny Zeta's) are in the oven now (they freeze really well) but this year I got a wild hair and decided to try a chocolate-burbon pecan pie, which I made and froze last week. I'm going to be really curious to see which one the guests like best!

From Beverly Mills - November 24, 2009

From Helen, via Facebook: 6 pies (coconut cream, pumpkin, walnut orange-2 each), a cake, cranberry, applesauce, chicken stock for gravy, mini oreo cheesecakes in fridge, and asparagus casserole in the freezer, moving on to pudding for banana pudding, and stuffing. feeding 20 + 4 kids . .

From Beverly Mills - November 27, 2009

From Jason, via Facebook: Corn casserole, broccoli and cauliflower casserole, vidalia onion pie, a dressing recipe from Tyler Florence and beet and bean salad (a family recipe). Happy Thanksgiving and happy eating!

From Beverly Mills - November 27, 2009

From Jeff, via Facebook: One turkey breast, an apricot chicken and a Tofurky.

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.

Related Recipes

Pumpkin, Sweet Potato and Peanut Soup

Pumpkin, Sweet Potato and Peanut Soup

October 18, 2010

You can call this Jack-O-Lantern Soup for Halloween, but by Thanksgiving, it becomes Pumpkin, Sweet Potato and Peanut Soup.

Read full recipe.